Maggies Closet

About Us

Open Since 2013

Maggie’s Closet was opened with a vision in mind. Forged from a love shopping for high end bargains and a dislike of having to search through rack after rack to find a great item this business was born. Maggie’s closet is a consignment shop that felt more like a boutique, where every rack was filled with “the good stuff”.
Not only was this business inclusive of brands it is also of great importance to us that women of all sizes and shapes to be able to shop together. That’s why we offer junior size 0 clothes through women’s plus size 3X. After all, it’s not fun watching someone else shop!
The decision to carry purses, women’s shoes, jewelry and accessories was easy. There’s a line from the movie “Steele Magnolias” that states, “What separates us from the animals is our ability to accessorize!”. I couldn’t agree more.
I hope you stop in Maggie’s Closet and see what we’ve done with the place. With over 500 items coming in weekly, there’s always a new treasure to be found.

Junior- Misses- Women’s- Plus Size- Jewlery- Purses- Accessories- Home Decor- Furniture

What do we offer?

Junior- Misses- Womens

clothing- accessories- shoes- jewlery-

Home Decor and Furniture

Everything from prints to candleabras everything you need for decoration makeover! Dining room tables, couches, chairs, cabinets, and conversation pieces!

Special Occasion

Evening, Cocktail, Mother of the Groom or Bride, and Prom!
Now Featuring Wedding Gowns!

Vintage Clothing!

Dresses, skirts, shirts, mens, womens, and more! We have items dating from the early 1900's for vintage clothing! We have a variety of leather and fur coats!

Local Art

Featuring of local artist Alli Schwartz throughout the store! See her murals in our changing rooms and her one of a kind hand-painted works available for purchase!

Maggie's Closet is one of the largest consignment shops in southeastern Wisconsin with two floors of amazing deals.

Now available!

Featuring local artists, hand crafted up-cycled apparel and hand selected vintage clothing selection!

Vintage Clothing!

Reach out today to book a consignment appointment to bring in your vintage gems today!Check out our growing Vintage Clothing Area in the lower level!!!

Feature local art!

Our Daughter, Alli Schwartz, is a very talented artist! You can find her incredible art on the walls of the dressing rooms!

Now available!

Find hand painted cards done by Alli Schwartz near our front counter!

Located in beautiful downtown Plymouth! Come visit us!