Welcome to Maggie's Closet!
Maggie’s Closet is one of the largest consignment stores in southeastern Wisconsin, now with two locations — our flagship store in Plymouth featuring two full floors of amazing deals, and our newest expansion in Milwaukee’s Third Ward. We’re proud to bring our signature experience to a new community while continuing to serve loyal shoppers in our original space.
We offer brand-name clothing for women, men, juniors, and vintage lovers! We also have plus sized options! Along with a wide selection of jewelry, purses, accessories, furniture, and home décor. But Maggie’s Closet is more than just a place to find great deals — it’s a space to recycle and refresh your wardrobe in a meaningful way.
Since opening in 2013, we’ve built a community rooted in connection, creativity, and sustainability. Many of the same consignors and shoppers who supported us in our earliest days are still part of our story today. To many, Maggie’s Closet feels like family — a place to chat, connect, and shop with joy. Each of our team members is passionate about consignment, and that warmth shines through the moment you walk in the door.
Think of us as your stylish sister’s or best friend’s closet — comfortable, welcoming, and always full of surprises. Whether you’re in the mood for fashion, furniture, or just good conversation, Maggie’s Closet continues to be a space where personal style and community come together.
We would love to meet you! Come visit us at one, or both, of our locations!
Interested in finding out more information? Click a button below!
About Us
Open Since 2013
Maggie’s Closet was opened with a vision in mind. Forged from a love shopping for high end bargains and a dislike of having to search through rack after rack to find a great item, this business was born. Maggie’s Closet is a consignment shop that feels more like a boutique, where every rack is filled with “the good stuff”.
Not only does our store offer the best brands, we are a size inclusive environment. It is of great importance to us that women of all sizes and shapes to be able to shop together. That’s why we offer junior size 0 clothes through women’s plus size 3X. After all, it’s not fun watching someone else shop!
The decision to carry purses, women’s shoes, jewelry and accessories is the “sprinkles on top of the sundae”! There’s a line from the movie “Steele Magnolias” that states, “What separates us from the animals is our ability to accessorize!”. We couldn’t agree more! Make sure to check out our wide selection of shoe brands from Lands End, Nike, Born, UGG, Keen, Sam Edelman, Allen Edmonds and so much more.
Designer Purses range from Coach to Arcadia, Vera Bradley to Lodis and a variety of name brands in between!
In addition to all the amazing choices we have for the ladies, we have added a section for the men to shop. Our lower level offers a hand selected variety of brand names that included Orvis, Lands End , Tommy Bahama, Cruel, Ralph Lauren, Levi, Greg Norman, Nike, Adidas and more!
Formal Dresses range from Evening Gowns to Prom to Mother’s Dresses, Short Formal/Cocktail Dresses and NEW in 2023 Wedding Dresses!!
We hope you stop at Maggie’s Closet and see what we’ve done with our beautiful turn of the 19th century historic building in the heart of downtown Plymouth, Wisconsin. With 500-700 new items coming in weekly, there’s always a new treasure to be found!