About Us

One of Southeastern Wisconsin's largest consignment stores

Maggie’s Closet is one of the largest consignment shops in southeastern Wisconsin with two floors of amazing deals. Featuring brand name junior, misses, women’s and plus size clothing, an assortment of jewelry, purses, accessories and home decor.

Maggie’s Closet offers more than unique finds and a way for Wisconsin ladies to recycle, and refresh their wardrobe. Here we also offer a unique shopping experience, that brings consignors and shoppers coming back. Many of the same shoppers, consignors and fans who supported the shop in its first year back in 2013 are still loyal clients today.

To many of our clients, Maggie’s Closet is a family. A place to chat, enjoy each others company, and of course shop! Each of our employees have a passion for consignment, and you feel that when you step into Maggie’s Closet and you are greeted with a smile. Imagine going through a sister or friend’s closet – comfortable and intriguing . Maggie’s Closet has something for everyone from clothing and home decor, to accessories and furniture. Not only do we offer a way to express your style but also an experience based in the support of a great community of individuals who are like minded.

Again- We have something for everyone!

Our Inventory includes the following:

CLOTHING: Junior girls, misses, women’s, and women’s plus sizes


SHOES: Women’s size 5 and up


JEWELRY: Earrings, necklaces, bracelets, pins and rings


PURSES: Every size and shape!




ACCESSORIES: Scarves, belts, wallets, etc.


HOME DECOR ITEMS: We have a great variety including, but not limited to; rugs, dishes, glassware, pottery, pictures, frames, mirrors, lamps, jewelry boxes and an array of unique decorative items.


FURNITUREAgain we offer a variety of furniture. Tables, Chairs, Couches, Benches, Display Cabinents (you never know what might be on the floor!)





Why Consign and Shop at Maggie's?

Numbers Speak For Themselves

0 +
Years of Experience
0 +
Items Sold

A Little
The Owners
Hi! We are the Schwartz Family!

Hi there! I am Dawn Schwartz and please enjoy this photo of my wonderful family! My husband Tim and I own Maggie’s Closet. We feel beyond blessed to have been given the opportunity to become the new owners of Maggie’s Closet after the Founder Gina Chandler decided to start the newest chapter in her life, Retirement. This, like everything in our life is a family affair. Our kids, Klairice, Alli, and Austin will frequently be in the shop helping out wherever needed. We can’t wait to meet you!