About Us
Come Visit One of Southeastern Wisconsin's Largest Consignment Stores!
Maggie’s Closet is one of the largest consignment shops in southeastern Wisconsin, now with two locations — our flagship store in Plymouth featuring two full floors of amazing deals, and our newest expansion in Milwaukee’s Third Ward, which will opened in July 2025. We’re proud to bring our signature experience to a new community while continuing to serve loyal shoppers in our original space.
We offer brand-name clothing for women, men, juniors, and vintage lovers! We also have plus sized options! Along with a wide selection of jewelry, purses, accessories, furniture, and home décor. But Maggie’s Closet is more than just a place to find great deals — it’s a space to recycle and refresh your wardrobe in a meaningful way.
Since opening in 2013, we’ve built a community rooted in connection, creativity, and sustainability. Many of the same consignors and shoppers who supported us in our earliest days are still part of our story today. To many, Maggie’s Closet feels like family — a place to chat, connect, and shop with joy. Each of our team members is passionate about consignment, and that warmth shines through the moment you walk in the door.
Think of us as your stylish sister’s or best friend’s closet — comfortable, welcoming, and always full of surprises. Whether you’re in the mood for fashion, furniture, or just good conversation, Maggie’s Closet continues to be a space where personal style and community come together.
Numbers Speak For Themselves
Our Inventory includes the following:
CLOTHING: Women’s, Juniors, Mens, Vintage, and plus sizes
SHOES: Women’s size 5 and up
JEWELRY: Earrings, necklaces, bracelets, pins and rings
PURSES: Every size and shape!
Wedding Dress: A variety of styles and oh so reasonable!
Featured Brands: From Harley Davidson to Patagonia! Come and shop with us!
ACCESSORIES: Scarves, belts, wallets, etc.
HOME DECOR ITEMS: We have a great variety including, but not limited to; rugs, dishes, glassware, pottery, pictures, frames, mirrors, lamps, jewelry boxes and an array of unique decorative items.
FURNITURE: Again we offer a variety of furniture. Tables, Chairs, Couches, Benches, Display Cabinets (you never know what might be on the floor!)
_
A Little
About
The Owners
-
Hi! We are the Schwartz Family!
Hi there! I am Dawn Schwartz and please enjoy this photo of my wonderful family! My husband Tim and I own Maggie’s Closet. We feel beyond blessed to have been given the opportunity to be the owners of Maggie’s Closet. This, like everything in our life, is a family affair. Our kids, Klairice, Alli, and Austin will regularly be seen in the shop. Alli is in charge of managing our Third Ward location, Austin can be seen at either location helping out wherever needed. Klairice frequents our stores whenever she is in the area. We look forward to seeing you soon!