Consignment

Working with Maggie's Closet Allows For

Clearing Your Closet, Earning Some Cash, and Doing Good

 

Consigning your clothes is a win-win. You turn your gently worn items into cash or store credit, giving your wardrobe new value without waste. It’s a simple way to declutter your closet, free up space, and keep your style in rotation — all while helping the planet. Instead of tossing clothes into landfills, you give them a second life in someone else’s wardrobe. Less clutter for you, less waste for the world, and more opportunity to shop smarter.

Shopping with Purpose: Style That’s Sustainable

Choosing secondhand isn’t just smart — it’s sustainable. Every gently loved piece you purchase helps reduce waste, conserve resources, and extend the life of quality items. By shopping consignment, you’re not only curbing the demand for mass production, you’re also keeping clothing and home goods out of landfills. We’re proud to offer our community an eco-conscious alternative that’s as unique and inspiring as the pieces we carry.

It Is What We Do!

Consignment is a wonderful way for you to earn money on items you once loved!
Maggie’s Closet carries high-end, name brand clothing that’s in great shape and currently in style. Our space is limited so we can’t afford to take items that aren’t in like new condition.
We have four seasons in Wisconsin, and we follow this guidline when accepting clothing! Your seasonal appointment is meant for clothing, accessories, purses, shoes, and NOT home decor. Please email us a photo, information, and dimensions of home decor and furniture that you would like to consign.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Do I Consign at Maggie's Closet?

The first step is to go through your items and eliminate anything that’s damaged, stained, faded or showing signs of wear.

Next, refer to the chart below. If you look at the first column, it tells you what month you need to call. Then follow it to the right, it will tell you what months you will be booking for and the final column tells you the season. For example, call in the month of April to book for August & September to bring in your fall clothing items. PLEASE NOTE, you will need to call or stop by on the first or second day of the month listed. Typically, when we start taking appointments, the months we are opening will fill within the day! We Do Not make appointments from email,facebook,or voicemails.

How Long Are My Items Available For Sale?

Seasonal items will be marked at full price for a minimum of 60 days. After 60 or more days, they will be marked at 50% off. If they are still available when the season ends, they are donated to the organization of our choosing or further discounted for a special sale.
Items such as Formal Dresses, Wedding Dresses, Home Decor and Furniture run on a separate schedule for discount, return or donation. This timeline is discussed when you meet with us to consign those items.

Is There a Consignment Contract?

Yes. All new consignors are required to sign a consignment contract at their first appointment. This agreement outlines important details such as how pricing works, how long items stay on the floor, and how payouts are handled. It helps ensure a smooth and transparent process for everyone involved.

*For Appointments Please Note*

Generally, appointments are Monday-Friday between 10:30 a.m. and 3pm.Wednesday we are open until 7p.m. so evening appointments can be scheduled as late as 4:30pm Please note, we do limit the number of items to a maximum of 30 items per visit. This allows us to get all of your items tagged and on the floor the same day they arrive. In order to make the check-in process go quickly, we ask that you please have your clothing folded neatly and freshly laundered in a box or laundry basket or plastic container. The only items we prefer brought in on hangers are Formal Dresses and Wedding Dresses.
Please Call or Email to set an appointment for Formals and Wedding Dresses. These appointments are separate from seasonal appointments.

If you'd like to book a consignment appointment at our Third Ward location you can do that below!